SAAIL Lab Publications
Scientific Reports · Nature · 2021 45+ Citations Prior Institutional Research · Pre-IITMZ (2021)

Prediction of precise subsoiling based on analytical method, discrete element simulation and experimental data from soil bin

Nelson Richard Makange 1 , Changying Ji 1 , Innocent Nyalala 1 , Idris Idris Sunusi 1 , Samwel Opiyo 1
1College of Engineering, Nanjing Agricultural University, Nanjing, China
Scientific Reports (Nature Portfolio) (May 2021)

Summary: Validates analytical models and discrete element method (DEM) soil-tillage simulations against controlled soil-bin measurements (45+ citations).

Abstract

Combines analytical soil mechanics, Discrete Element Method (DEM) modeling, and instrumented soil-bin experiments to predict draft forces and disturbance profiles for precision agricultural subsoiling implements.

Keywords: precision subsoilingDEM simulationsoil binScientific Reportsagricultural engineering

Key Findings & Contributions

R² = 0.984
DEM Prediction R²
NRMSE = 1.936 (p < 0.05)
R² = 0.957
Analytical Model R²
NRMSE = 6.008 (McKyes eq.)
p > 0.93
ANOVA Force Agreement
p = 0.9396 H / 0.9696 V
Nat. SciRep
Nature Portfolio
45+ citations
  1. Integrated elastoplastic soil behavior into Discrete Element Method (DEM) simulations alongside modified-McKyes and Willat-Willis analytical tillage equations.
  2. Validated subsoiling draft forces and furrow soil disturbance profiles in controlled soil-bin trolley force-sensor trials using Taguchi design.
  3. Proved DEM outperforms analytical approximation at R² = 0.984 (NRMSE 1.936) vs. R² = 0.957 (NRMSE 6.008) with statistically aligned ANOVA forces.

Benchmark Results

Analytical vs. Discrete Element Simulation Accuracy on Soil-Bin Force Trials

Modeling ApproachRegression R²Normalized RMSESignificance / Finding
Discrete Element Method (DEM)0.9841.936Captures elastoplastic soil failure (p < 0.05)
Analytical Model (Modified-McKyes)0.9576.008Closed-form force & furrow approximation

BibTeX

@article{makange2021subsoiling,
  title={Prediction of precise subsoiling based on analytical method, discrete element simulation and experimental data from soil bin},
  author={Makange, Nelson Richard and Ji, Changying and Nyalala, Innocent and Sunusi, Idris Idris and Opiyo, Samwel},
  journal={Scientific Reports},
  year={2021},
  doi={10.1038/s41598-021-90682-w},
  publisher={Nature Portfolio}
}
APA Citation

Makange, N. R., Ji, C., Nyalala, I., Sunusi, I. I., & Opiyo, S. (2021). Prediction of precise subsoiling based on analytical method, discrete element simulation and experimental data from soil bin. Scientific Reports. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-90682-w